The rollout of Form 1099-DA was supposed to bring order to crypto tax compliance. Instead, it’s exposing how broken the system has been all along.
Brokers began issuing the new form in February, marking the first time centralized exchanges are required to report digital asset sales directly to the IRS. But the form only captures half the equation. It shows proceeds—what investors received when they sold. It doesn’t show cost basis—what they originally paid. Without both numbers, calculating actual tax liability is impossible.
That gap is forcing investors to dig through years of transaction records, often across multiple platforms and wallets, to reconstruct data their software should have been tracking all along.
Janna Scott saw this reckoning coming.
Scott, founder of the crypto tax platform DeFi Tax, spent two years researching the industry before launching this month. Her investigation began in December 2021 after accounting clients asked a question she couldn’t confidently answer: were their crypto tax reports accurate?
She decided to find out. Scott took one wallet and ran it through fourteen major tax platforms. She expected small variations. She got fourteen completely different outcomes—some diverging by tens of thousands of dollars on identical transaction data.
“I kept seeing the same pattern,” Scott said. “People thought their taxes were handled until an audit or notice showed up. When I audited crypto tax platforms themselves, I realized many of them couldn’t explain their own numbers.”

A Form That Exposes the Problem
The 1099-DA doesn’t create new tax obligations. Crypto has been taxable for years. What the form does is give the IRS a direct data feed from exchanges—proceeds figures it can match against filed returns.
For 2025 transactions, brokers report proceeds only. Cost basis reporting begins next year, but only for assets purchased on or after January 1, 2026, held continuously on the same exchange until sale. Anything transferred between platforms, moved to a personal wallet, or purchased before the cutoff date will show no basis.
That leaves millions of investors holding forms that tell the IRS what they sold but not what they owe. The burden of proving basis falls entirely on the taxpayer.
Scott’s research, conducted in collaboration with the SEC, IRS, and academic institutions, revealed that most tax platforms weren’t built to handle this burden—especially for investors engaged in anything beyond basic trading.
“Most tools were designed for basic buy-and-sell activity,” Scott said. “Once you introduce DeFi, LPs, bridges, and wrapping, the math breaks. The biggest issue isn’t missing features; it’s the lack of explainability. If you can’t explain how a number was calculated, it won’t hold up under audit.”

Where the Form Doesn’t Reach
Centralized exchanges issue 1099-DAs. Decentralized protocols do not. Liquidity pools, token bridges, wrapped assets, peer-to-peer swaps, staking rewards, airdrops—none of this activity appears on the form.
A requirement that DeFi platforms begin reporting in 2027 was repealed earlier this year, leaving a permanent gap in coverage.
For investors active across both centralized and decentralized platforms, the 1099-DA represents only a partial picture. Everything else requires manual tracking, accurate record-keeping, and software capable of interpreting complex on-chain activity.
Most platforms fall short, Scott said.
“Bridging isn’t selling, and wrapping isn’t disposal, but most software treats them that way,” she said. “DeFi activity exposes the cracks in legacy tax logic.”
The problem compounds when platforms allow manual edits. Adjusting timestamps, reclassifying transactions, or modifying cost basis might resolve an immediate error, but it destroys the audit trail.
“Automation without transparency is just a faster risk,” Scott said.
Blockchain as the Record
DeFi Tax operates on a different principle. The platform pulls data directly from the blockchain—the immutable ledger where every transaction is permanently recorded. No CSV uploads. No manual adjustments. No editable fields.
“We don’t optimize for speed or simplicity at the expense of accuracy,” Scott said. “DeFi Tax is built around audit defense. Every figure needs to be traceable, consistent, and defensible. That mindset changes everything about how the system is designed.”
The distinction matters because audit-ready doesn’t mean correct. It means documented. It means a report can answer follow-up questions.
“An auditor doesn’t just want totals,” Scott said. “They want to know how you got there. Audit-ready reporting is structured, consistent, and explainable.”
The Compliance Era Begins
The IRS now receives copies of every 1099-DA. Automated matching systems compare those forms against filed returns. Mismatches trigger notices. The informal era of crypto tax reporting is closing.
“As reporting requirements tighten, crypto audits are becoming more common,” Scott said. “The risk isn’t just enforcement; it’s being unprepared when questions come.”
With April 15 approaching, Scott said investors should act now.
“Don’t wait until tax season or an audit to understand your exposure,” she said. “If you can’t explain your report today, that’s a signal to fix it.”
The confusion this season, she added, reflects a broader misunderstanding about what crypto investors are actually trying to do.
“Most people aren’t trying to avoid crypto taxes,” Scott said. “They’re trying to understand them.”






